What started out as a small request to add an option to compare the same day of week instead of day of month from one year ago, ballooned into a much bigger project that took about 10 days of work. A lot of our code for graphs and trends is pretty old, so a large portion of this update was just cleaning that up significantly so future updates like this should be a lot easier.
Most websites have consistent patterns of traffic on each unique day of the week, or at least significant weekday vs weekend differences, so it makes sense that the day of week should always match when comparing the past.
That’s a big part of what this update is about. The default trend before was “yesterday”, it is now “7 days ago”. You can of course change this back to “yesterday” using the trend menu or in your user preferences. We’ve also added a new “28 days ago” option and rephrased a few of the others:
Likewise with graphs, part of the reason we’ve always had “last 28 days” as one of the default options was so that when comparing the immediately preceding period, the days of week would line up. We’ve kept the “28 days” as standard for the smallest option for now, but no matter what date range you choose now, the days of week will ALWAYS line up, so you’re always comparing apples to apples. Days of week also always match for trend percentages too.
The tooltip for secondary comparison lines is also now properly labeled. The correct value was always shown before, but the label displayed was for the primary line, which didn’t matter for comparing two unique data types, but was horribly confusing when comparing the same data type over two date ranges.
We’ve also cleaned up and simplified the hourly comparison section at the top of the menu, and added a “28 days ago” option here as well, for data types that support hourly data:
Lastly, in the “Compare…” menu, you could choose a specific data type and item of that type to compare against. E.g. if you were viewing your visitor graph, you could click “Compare…”, then “Countries”, then “United States”, to see how many visitors were from the US vs total visitors. However, you could only choose from the top 20 items in that cateogry. This was fine if the item you were interested in was one of the top items, but if it was more of a long tail item you wanted to view, you were out of luck. We’ve increased this limit to 50 now. Ideally we would add some kind of pagination or “more…” link so it was limitless, but for now this is very helpful for the way we use Clicky ourselves.
The trends knowledgebase article was given a hefty update which we highly recommend reading. It contains a lot of good information for how date ranges are calculated when matching day of week, and things like that. It also has a nice new screenshot showing what exactly the trend option you select does in the reporting interface, which I’ll copy here as well:
One final change is that daily graphs now always show the “previous period” comparison by default. Before, you had to load this via the “Compare…” menu, and I honestly don’t think enough people know that that menu is even there. Also the inconsistency between the default of hourly graphs always showing comparison data, but daily never showing it, was really bugging me. It’s been like that since we added hourly data around 10 years ago. It may throw you off a bit because you’re only used to seeing in the visitor graph, but give it a chance to grow on you.
This is a great update, because comparing to 7 days ago makes a lot more sense given that each day of the week tends to have its own dynamics as you mentioned. Traffic on weekends tends to be higher for example. I appreciate this update, its a good one!
Glad you like it!
Interesting update ! However, how can I disable on the main page (https://clicky.com/user/), the “previous period” graph from appearing every time. I find it confusing on this page to have it now.
This tweak was actually added a few days later, because the inconsistency between hourly graphs always showing comparison graphs by default, but daily graphs NOT doing that by default, was really bugging me. It threw me off a bit too but give it a chance to grow on you.
After the graphs update, I observe different (incorrect) behavior with the current period / past period charts on the main dashboard (I haven’t looked in charts for individual properties).
Basically, the chart works only if we compare visitor numbers. As soon as we select another metric from the column below ‘Today’ (Actions, Bounce rate, Average time, Goals) the chart for the current period will draw correctly but the chart for the previous period will remain showing the visitors.
This behavior is replicated if I switch the scope from 28 days to another period (e.g. weekly, monthly). Chart for current period updates, chart for previos period still shows visitor count.
Here is a 38-second YouTube video that shows the issue. Let’s hope my post doesn’t get flagged because of this.
Link to video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R82IDuT1GgM
4 days later my comment is still ‘awaiting moderation’ but the fault is already fixed 🙂
Sorry, still not used to our new blog where I actually have to approve comments. Only remember to do it a few times per month. 🙂
But yes someone else emailed us about this bug and we got it fixed!
I’d rather have the default left like it was, comparing today with yesterday. Is there a way I can change it back?
Yes, the last screenshot shows how to change the preference!
Comments are closed.